The supplier calls: cloth is going up ten per cent from next week. The order quoted last month is still on the floor. A ten per cent rise sounds small. As a share of the profit it is not, because the cloth is most of the cost and the profit is a thin slice of the price.
Why a small rise is a large share
In the mark-up and margin article the fabric was ₹420 of a ₹640 direct cost, about 66%. A rise in the biggest line moves the cost more than a rise in any other. And since the price was fixed when the order was accepted, the whole rise comes out of the profit.
A worked example
These figures are made up to show the sum. They are not a benchmark, not a fabric price and not a claim about any supplier. The garment is that same costing example: direct cost ₹640, a 3% rejection allowance and 12% overhead make a total cost of ₹738.30. A 35% mark-up gives a price of ₹996.71 and a profit of ₹258.41, which is a margin of 25.9%.
Now the fabric rises by 10%, which is ₹42. The rejection allowance grows with it, because a rejected garment now wastes dearer cloth: 3% of ₹42 is ₹1.26. The rent and the supervisor cost the same as before, so the overhead does not move. The rise costs ₹43.26 a garment. The total cost is ₹781.56. With the price unchanged at ₹996.71:
- Profit: ₹996.71 − ₹781.56 = ₹215.15, down from ₹258.41.
- Margin: 21.6%, down from 25.9%.
- Profit lost: 16.7% of it, from a rise of 10% in the cloth.
Five, ten and twenty per cent
- Up 5%: ₹21.63 more cost, profit ₹236.78, margin 23.8%, profit down 8.4%.
- Up 10%: ₹43.26 more, profit ₹215.15, margin 21.6%, profit down 16.7%.
- Up 20%: ₹86.52 more, profit ₹171.89, margin 17.2%, profit down 33.5%.
Putting the price right
- To keep the same profit in rupees: raise the price by ₹43.26, to ₹1,039.97. That is 4.3%.
- To keep the same 25.9% margin: the price must be ₹781.56 ÷ 0.7407 = ₹1,055.11, which is 5.9% more. The margin is a share of the price, so the price has to rise by more than the cost.
- On an order of 1,000 garments: ₹43,260 more cost, out of a profit of ₹2,58,406.
The shortcut over-charges a little
Rebuild the quote with the flat 12% overhead on the new direct cost and the cost rises by ₹48.45. The rise really costs ₹43.26. The ₹5.19 is overhead that was never spent.
What to do with it
- Put a date on every quote. A price that is open for a week is not exposed to a rise the week after.
- Buy for confirmed orders. Cloth bought before the rise belongs to the order, not to the new price.
- Keep the wastage low. At ₹420 a garment, every point of wastage the marker article saves is worth more when the price rises.
- Count the cloth by the metre. The fabric consumption article shows how to know what a garment really takes.
What the sums leave out
- Made-up numbers. The 10% and the cost sheet are assumptions. Use your own.
- Cloth already bought. Stock at the old price lowers the average for the orders it goes into.
- The buyer. A higher price may not be accepted, and the profit on the order may be what is paid for the relationship.
- The cash. Dearer cloth also needs more money before the order pays, as in the cash needed article.
Put your own fabric, trims and making into the garment costing calculator, raise the fabric by the rise you are told, and read what happens to the price you need.