Business

Repair or Replace: When an Old Machine Costs More

A rusty steel tray holding bobbin cases, bent needles and a presser foot, beside a wooden-handled screwdriver, a small oil can and a piece of grey card, on a terracotta background

Every unit has one: a machine that has been repaired so often the mechanic knows it by name. Each repair bill is small, so it never looks like the moment to replace it. But the bill is only half the cost. The other half is the operator standing beside it, waiting.

Two costs, not one

  • The repair itself — parts and the mechanic's time. It is on a receipt, so it is remembered.
  • The stopped operator — every minute the machine is down, a paid person is not sewing. It is on no receipt, so it is usually forgotten.

The second cost is often the larger. It is the same arithmetic as in the absent operator article: a machine that is down is an operator who is absent from that post, with the difference that the operator is still on the payroll.

A worked example

These figures are made up to show the sum. They are not a benchmark, not a claim about any machine or brand, and not a promise of how often a new machine will stop. Use your own.

  • The old machine: repairs and parts cost ₹1,200 a month, and it stops 5 times a month, 45 minutes each time, from the operator putting up a hand to the machine running again. That is 5 × 45 = 225 minutes a month.
  • The minute rate: borrowed from the rejects and rework article. A ₹120 stitching cost over an 18-minute garment is ₹120 ÷ 18 = ₹6.67 a minute (exactly six and two-thirds, shown rounded).
  • The new machine: ₹60,000 including tax, service ₹200 a month. Assume it stops once a month for 45 minutes. This is an assumption, and a large one; see below.
  • The old machine, if sold: ₹12,000.

What the old machine costs a month

  • Repairs: ₹1,200.
  • Idle operator: 225 minutes × ₹6.67 = about ₹1,500.
  • Total: ₹2,700 a month, ₹32,400 a year.

The receipts show ₹1,200. The real figure is more than twice that.

What the new one would cost

  • Service: ₹200.
  • Idle operator: 45 minutes × ₹6.67 = ₹300.
  • Total: ₹500 a month.

The difference is ₹2,200 a month. Against the ₹60,000 price that is 60,000 ÷ 2,200 = 27.3 months. Selling the old machine for ₹12,000 brings the sum to 48,000 ÷ 2,200 = 21.8 months.

Count the minutes, not the receipts Keep a log by the machine: the date, the minutes it was down, and what the repair cost. A month of that log is worth more than any opinion about whether the machine is “getting old”.

Which post it sits at changes the answer

The sum above counts one idle operator. That is right if the machine is at a post with spare capacity, where the rest of the line can carry on. If it is at the slowest operation, the whole line waits, as in the line balancing article.

Take the same line of 12 operators. The line's minute is 12 × ₹6.67 = ₹80 a minute, the cost of every operator waiting at once.

  • Old machine at the slowest post: ₹1,200 + 225 × ₹80 = ₹19,200 a month.
  • New machine there: ₹200 + 45 × ₹80 = ₹3,800 a month.
  • Difference: ₹15,400 a month. The ₹48,000 left after selling the old one is paid back in 3.1 months.

Same machine, same price, same repairs: 21.8 months at one post, 3.1 months at another. Where the machine stands matters more than how old it is. It is also why the first thing to know about a stopping machine is which post it is on.

The assumption that carries the sum

Everything above rests on the new machine stopping once a month instead of five times. Nothing in a brochure or a quotation can tell you that. Test it: if the new one stopped just as often, its cost would be ₹200 + 225 × ₹6.67 = ₹1,700 a month, the saving would be only ₹1,000, and the ₹48,000 would take 48 months.

So ask what is actually causing the stops. If it is the age of the machine, a new one helps. If it is thread, needles, oil, a worn part that can be replaced for a few hundred rupees, or the way the machine is used, a new machine will stop for the same reasons.

What the sums leave out

  • Made-up numbers. The repair cost, stops, minutes, price and resale value are all assumptions. Replace every one with a figure from your own log.
  • Quality. A machine that skips stitches or puckers makes rework. The rejects article puts that in rupees, and it is not counted here.
  • The first weeks. A new machine needs setting and the operator needs to get used to it. Some output is lost at the start.
  • How the purchase is paid for. The payback above ignores interest. If the machine is bought on a loan, work out the instalment as well, as in the payback and EMI article.
  • The old machine's other uses. A machine that is poor at the slowest post may be perfectly good at a post with spare capacity. Moving it can cost nothing.

Put your own saving and price into the machine payback calculator and see how many months it takes, then check that the instalment is covered by the saving in your worst month, not your best.

Was this guide useful?

Read next

Related guides