Business

Job Work or Do It In-house: Which Costs Less?

A folded white shirt lying in an open brown cardboard box, with a coil of jute twine and a blank cream paper tag on a string beside it on a teal background

Some steps of a garment can be sent out to a job worker instead of done in the unit. The job worker's rate is easy to read, and the in-house cost is not. The two are only equal on one condition: that your own operator and machine are busy all day.

What each side really costs

  • Job work: the rate, plus the transport both ways, plus the days the garments are away.
  • In-house: the operator's wage and the machine's running cost, divided by the garments they really make.

A worked example

These figures are made up to show the sum. They are not a benchmark and not a claim about any job worker or any operation. One operation takes 1.2 minutes a garment. An operator is paid ₹3,200 for 480 minutes and works at 80% of the standard. The machine, its power and its upkeep are assumed to cost ₹250 a day.

  • Garments a day: 480 ÷ 1.2 × 0.8 = 320.
  • Wage per garment: ₹3,200 ÷ 320 = ₹10.00.
  • Machine per garment: ₹250 ÷ 320 = ₹0.78.
  • In-house, fully busy: ₹10.78 a garment.
  • Job work: an assumed ₹11.00 rate plus ₹0.80 for transport = ₹11.80 a garment.

On a fully busy day, doing it in-house saves ₹1.02 a garment. On an order of 3,000 garments, which is 9.4 days of work, that is ₹35,400 − ₹32,344 = ₹3,056.

When the answer turns round

The wage and the machine are paid whether the operator is busy or not. If this work fills only half of the days, the other half is still paid, and the in-house cost doubles: ₹10.78 ÷ 0.5 = ₹21.56. That is far above ₹11.80. The two costs meet when the operator is busy ₹10.78 ÷ ₹11.80 = 91% of the time. Below that, job work is cheaper.

The opposite case matters too. If an operator is already on the payroll and has no other work that day, the wage is spent either way, and only the machine's ₹0.78 is new. Against ₹11.80, that is clear: keep it in-house.

Ask how busy the operator will be The in-house cost per garment is not a fixed number. It is the day's cost divided by the garments really made, so a half-busy operator costs twice as much per garment.

What to do with it

  • Compare at your real busy-ness, not at a full day. Count the days the operator has this work in the month.
  • Add the days away. Garments at a job worker are work in progress; the work in progress article puts them in rupees.
  • Ask about rework. A garment sent back costs transport again and the minutes to correct it, as the rejects article shows.
  • Keep the quote with the cost. The cut-and-make rate article shows how your own step costs build up.

What the sums leave out

  • Made-up numbers. The minutes, the 80%, the ₹250 and the rates are assumptions.
  • Quality and control. Work outside the unit is checked later, and corrected later.
  • The capacity you give up. A machine and operator freed from this step could do other work, which is worth something too.
  • The relationship. A job worker who is busy on your order is not busy on someone else's.

Put your own operators and hours into the production efficiency calculator to see what a person really makes in a day, then use that to compare with the job worker's rate.

Was this guide useful?

Read next

Related guides